Anduril, Flame of the West, forged from the Shards of Narsil, blade of Elendil of Numenor.
You've heard the name. You know how it goes.
But how does it handle? How does it sing in your hand as you slice (hopefully through orcs) and cry out as you cut through the host of the enemy (of tatami and water bottles, most likely)?
"It doesnt. There are no functional Andurils on the market - aside from the Museum Collection - and I dont have that kind of cash on me (see my collection of sliced bottles and tatami?)"
That was true.
But today, more and more makers are seeing what Telchar all those moons ago before forging what would be the greatest and most sought-after sword in cinematic and literary history:
Swordsmen want a legend and they're willing to empty their collective coin purse to get one.
Well, swordsman, now you can!
In typical Dwarven fashion, I've done the digging. Like a Dunedain, I've done all the watching you need to and like your friendly neighborhood Maia-turned-old wizard, I am not here to rob you. I'm here to help you.
I'm sifting through all the troll hoard filth that is scammy internet Andurils and dropping the loot right in your waiting lap. Stay with me and I'll show you on your moon map where the true Anduril waits for your royal grip and where the poor, wicked servants of the enemy lay in wait for your hard-earned cash, just to abandon you after the first
"For Frodo..."
Lords and ladies, nobles and commoners, your guide through the Mines of Mor-Anduril for Your Money has finally arrived.
As Gollum's finger once said after finding the One Ring, let's get into this...
Here in America, participation counts for something. With that in mind, I am going to be kind and present the Ryujin Ironwolf (Anduril) sword with a ribbon for last place - just SQUEAKING by here in the "functional" category for its attributes and for boldly daring to try in an industry full of wall hanging trash.
But let's be VERY CLEAR, The Ryujin Ironwolf ONLY looks the part and may not do in a pinch at Pelagir.
At first glance, it checks many of the boxes collectors are looking for: a 34-inch blade, respectable weight at just under four pounds, a comfortable point of balance, spring steel construction, and marketing that boldly proclaims it to be "battle ready straight out of the box."
Unfortunately, appearances can be deceiving.
The biggest issue isn't the blade. By all accounts, the 65Mn spring steel performs reasonably well for light backyard cutting. The problem lies where it matters most: the hilt construction.
Ryujin advertises a full tang with a peened pommel. That's simply not what you're getting.
Instead, the sword relies on a threaded construction (BOOO!) with exposed threads visible beneath the pommel. Worse still, the guard is made from zinc alloy rather than steel.
Either one of those compromises might be forgivable on a budget display piece. Together, they immediately raise questions about long-term durability.
Could you cut a few things with it?
Meh.
Could you should you carry it to Helm's Deep to help out Hama? Nah, Ma.
As promised, here are the stats for comparison, but keep reading and you'll be given the goods you'll want to be saving for:
RyanSword surprises me.
For around $400, you're getting a well-balanced 1095 high-carbon steel blade with a respectable distal taper, good temper, solid stiffness, and cutting performance that consistently impressed reviewers.
At just over four pounds with a point of balance around two inches from the guard, it handles much more like a real sword than many fantasy replicas ever do.
Unfortunately, the closer you look, the more compromises begin to appear. The alloy hilt replaces functional steel, the grip uses synthetic leather that has a tendency to shift under the hand, and while the tang appears solid, it's secured with a threaded pommel rather than a true peen.
Still, credit where it's due: RyanSword delivers an honest, capable cutter that doesn't pretend to be anything more than it is.
I own several RyanSwords and they're respectable, doing an admirable job (though a bit off balance and overweight in terms of Western swords). This seems a very respectable replica.
Just not yet the King of Gondor's - nor yours, my Prince.
Be brave, we're almost there.
This is where the list gets difficult. Because if I judged these swords on pure durability alone, Darksword Armory would probably finish even higher.
Plus, I myself have experienced all-out negligence, poor QC, and outright nonsense of this forge over and over again - HERE, HERE, HERE, EVERYWHERE! (no, Im not bitter and jaded), so they dont get a pass.
Blade: 5160 High Carbon Steel
The redesigned pommel allows for a proper (hot, so they say, it's epoxy and JB Weld, fuck off), peen, the blade geometry has improved, and the sword itself looks more robust than previous versions.
No, it isn't perfectly screen accurate. The blade lacks the signature hollow grind, the fuller stops well short of the tip, and instead of a traditional peened construction, Ronin secures the hilt with two exposed hex screws.
Purists may cringe. I don't.
Because unlike some decorative shortcuts, these are honest engineering decisions. Ronin isn't pretending to build a museum replica. They're building a sword designed to survive hard use, and by all accounts, it performs like a beast.
By all accounts, even if a troll bit my shiny pommel clean off, I could still fight with this riveted ranger's death reaper until the Army of the Dead came to save me and that's saying everything it needs to.
Could it be more faithful to the films? Absolutely. Would I carry it into battle before many prettier replicas? Without hesitation.
That's why Ronin earns one of the top spots.
Finally. This is the one. The King has Returned.
Unlike the other Andurils on this list, Swordier appears to have started with one simple question:
"How do we build the most functional version of Peter Lyon's legendary Andúril?"
The answers are impressive:
The blade is properly hollow ground (like the Museum Collection Anduril and the piece from the films), giving it the lively handling characteristics that made the original film sword so distinctive.
The distal taper has been improved and stiffened over the earlier generation.
The crossguard is functional mild steel instead of zinc for added defense.
The genuine leather grip wraps cleanly over wood with no gaps.
And perhaps most importantly... ...the tang is actually peened. Not hidden. Not threaded. Not covered up with clever marketing. Actually peened.
Yet even with all of that, Swordier's Anduril does not stop there.
They listened to the criticisms of the original model (too short, too floppy) and went back to work.
The new version of Anduril corrected and lengthened the blade to match (closely) the dimensions from Weta, stiffened the steel to eliminate the flop from previous iteration, and created better balance overall. Swordier's Anduril remains one of the ONLY production Andúrils to retain that beautiful hollow-ground blade that gives it both speed and authority in the cut.
Is it perfect? No.
The decorative gold inlays are painted rather than inlaid metal, and if you're planning on smashing rocks with it...well...don't. The edge will remind you that physics always wins.
But that's hardly the point.
For roughly $400, you're getting a sword that captures the spirit, handling, and engineering philosophy of Andúril better than anything else currently available. It isn't merely a beautiful replica.
It feels like a sword that could win back a kingdom. And at the end of the day, that's what we're doing here.
If Aragorn, Ma Keng, had to choose one production Andúril before marching to the Black Gate...he'd turn to me, his faithful squire, and THIS is the sword he would receive from my hand.
But if you've read this far, I suspect you're looking for something different. You want to know what it feels like to grip the Flame of the West.
To hear steel sing through a target. To own a sword worthy of the stories that inspired it.
For me, that's exactly why Swordier takes the crown.
The King has returned.
Now it's your turn.
Why does everyone keep talking about peened pommels?
Because Andúril isn't just supposed to look like a king's sword—it should be built like one.
COLLECTOR'S REC.
You finally found the right Andúril. Now all you need is the Ranger.
Whether you're heading to a Renaissance Faire, Comic Con, Halloween party, or simply want to display the sword the way the King of Gondor intended, this movie-inspired Aragorn Ranger costume completes the look surprisingly well. Pair it with a quality leather sword belt, lace-up boots, and your Andúril, and you're about as close as most of us will ever get to walking the paths of the Dúnedain.
No comments:
Post a Comment